The Monty Hall Problem
The Monty Hall Problem is a classic probability puzzle that has intrigued mathematicians and non-mathematicians alike since its introduction. The puzzle is named after the host of the game show "Let's Make a Deal," Monty Hall, who presented the problem to contestants on the show.
The Problem
The problem is as follows: imagine you are a contestant on a game show. The host, Monty Hall, presents you with three doors. Behind one of the doors is a car, and behind the other two doors are goats. You are asked to choose one of the doors, without opening it, and then Monty will open one of the other two doors that you did not choose to reveal a goat. At this point, Monty will ask you if you would like to switch your choice to the remaining unopened door or keep your original choice.
So, what should you do? Should you stick with your original choice or switch to the remaining door?
The Solution
The answer to this problem is not immediately obvious. In fact, many people's intuition leads them to believe that the odds of winning the car are the same whether they switch or not. However, this intuition is incorrect.
The key to understanding this problem lies in the fact that Monty knows what is behind each of the doors and will never reveal the car. Therefore, when Monty reveals a goat behind one of the other doors, he is giving you information about the location of the car.
To see this, consider the following scenarios:
-
You choose Door 1, and the car is behind Door 2. Monty reveals a goat behind Door 3. If you switch to Door 2, you win the car.
-
You choose Door 1, and the car is behind Door 3. Monty reveals a goat behind Door 2. If you switch to Door 3, you win the car.
-
You choose Door 2, and the car is behind Door 1. Monty reveals a goat behind Door 3. If you switch to Door 1, you win the car.
-
You choose Door 2, and the car is behind Door 3. Monty reveals a goat behind Door 1. If you switch to Door 3, you win the car.
-
You choose Door 3, and the car is behind Door 1. Monty reveals a goat behind Door 2. If you switch to Door 1, you win the car.
-
You choose Door 3, and the car is behind Door 2. Monty reveals a goat behind Door 1. If you switch to Door 2, you win the car.
In scenarios 1-3, if you switch, you win the car. In scenarios 4-6, if you switch, you also win the car. Therefore, the odds of winning the car if you switch are 2/3, while the odds of winning if you stick with your original choice are only 1/3.
Conclusion
The Monty Hall Problem is a great example of how our intuition can sometimes lead us astray, and how a little bit of mathematical reasoning can help us make better decisions. So, the next time you find yourself on a game show with three doors, remember to switch!